Pick | Team | Mel Kiper 4.0 | Pro Football Focus 3.0 | Website Consensus | Actual Draft |
 1 | | Caleb Williams QB USC | Caleb Williams QB USC | Caleb Williams QB USC Grade:2 | Caleb Williams QB USC |
 2 | | Jayden Daniels QB LSU | Drake Maye QB North Carolina | Jayden Daniels QB LSU Grade:5 | Jayden Daniels QB LSU |
 3 | | Drake Maye QB North Carolina | Jayden Daniels QB LSUTrade | Drake Maye QB North Carolina Grade:6 | Drake Maye QB North Carolina |
 4 | | Marvin Harrison Jr. WR Ohio State | Marvin Harrison Jr. WR Ohio State | Marvin Harrison Jr. WR Ohio State Grade:1 | Marvin Harrison Jr. WR Ohio State |
 5 | | J.J. McCarthy QB MichiganTrade | Malik Nabers WR LSU | J.J. McCarthy QB Michigan Grade:18 | Joe Alt OT Notre Dame |
 6 | | Malik Nabers WR LSU | Rome Odunze WR Washington | Malik Nabers WR LSU Grade:3 | Malik Nabers WR LSU |
 7 | | Joe Alt OT Notre Dame | Joe Alt OT Notre Dame | Joe Alt OT Notre Dame Grade:8 | JC Latham OT Alabama |
 8 | | Dallas Turner OLB Alabama | Laiatu Latu OLB UCLA | Dallas Turner OLB Alabama Grade:10 | Michael Penix Jr. QB Washington |
 9 | | Rome Odunze WR Washington | J.J. McCarthy QB MichiganTrade | Rome Odunze WR Washington Grade:15 | Rome Odunze WR Washington |
 10 | | Brock Bowers TE Georgia | Brock Bowers TE Georgia | Brock Bowers TE Georgia Grade:7 | J.J. McCarthy QB MichiganTrade |
 11 | | JC Latham OT Alabama | Terrion Arnold CB Alabama | JC Latham OT Alabama Grade:13 | Olumuyiwa Fashanu OT Penn State |
 12 | | Quinyon Mitchell CB Toledo | Michael Penix Jr. QB Washington | Bo Nix QB Oregon Grade:37 | Bo Nix QB Oregon |
 13 | | Taliese Fuaga OT Oregon State | Brian Thomas Jr. WR LSU | Michael Penix Jr. QB Washington Grade:27 | Brock Bowers TE Georgia |
 14 | | Olumuyiwa Fashanu OT Penn State | Taliese Fuaga OT Oregon State | Olumuyiwa Fashanu OT Penn State Grade:4 | Taliese Fuaga OT Oregon State |
 15 | | Terrion Arnold CB Alabama | Quinyon Mitchell CB ToledoTrade | Quinyon Mitchell CB Toledo Grade:9 | Laiatu Latu OLB UCLA |
 16 | | Troy Fautanu IOL Washington | Dallas Turner OLB Alabama | Troy Fautanu IOL Washington Grade:56 | Byron Murphy II DL Texas |
 17 | | Cooper DeJean CB Iowa | Cooper DeJean CB Iowa | Terrion Arnold CB Alabama Grade:11 | Dallas Turner OLB AlabamaTrade |
 18 | | Byron Murphy II DL Texas | Byron Murphy II DL Texas | Byron Murphy II DL Texas Grade:17 | Amarius Mims OT Georgia |
 19 | | Laiatu Latu OLB UCLA | Olumuyiwa Fashanu OT Penn State | Laiatu Latu OLB UCLA Grade:12 | Jared Verse OLB Florida State |
 20 | | Graham Barton OT Duke | Troy Fautanu IOL Washington | Graham Barton OT Duke Grade:46 | Troy Fautanu IOL Washington |
 21 | | Jared Verse OLB Florida State | Jer'Zhan Newton DL Illinois | Jer'Zhan Newton DL Illinois Grade:20 | Chop Robinson OLB Penn State |
 22 | | Nate Wiggins CB Clemson | Amarius Mims OT Georgia | Nate Wiggins CB Clemson Grade:22 | Quinyon Mitchell CB Toledo |
 23 | | Xavier Worthy WR TexasTrade | Jared Verse OLB Florida State | Chop Robinson OLB Penn State Grade:21 | Brian Thomas Jr. WR LSU |
 24 | | Tyler Guyton OT Oklahoma | Graham Barton OT Duke | Tyler Guyton OT Oklahoma Grade:30 | Terrion Arnold CB AlabamaTrade |
 25 | | Amarius Mims OT Georgia | Nate Wiggins CB Clemson | Cooper DeJean CB Iowa Grade:35 | Jordan Morgan OT Arizona |
 26 | | Chop Robinson OLB Penn State | Kool-Aid McKinstry CB Alabama | Kool-Aid McKinstry CB Alabama Grade:25 | Graham Barton OT Duke |
 27 | | Darius Robinson OLB Missouri | Chop Robinson OLB Penn State | Darius Robinson OLB Missouri Grade:26 | Darius Robinson OLB Missouri |
 28 | | Brian Thomas Jr. WR LSU | Adonai Mitchell WR Texas | Brian Thomas Jr. WR LSU Grade:23 | Xavier Worthy WR TexasTrade |
 29 | | Adonai Mitchell WR Texas | Payton Wilson LB NC State | Ennis Rakestraw Jr. CB Missouri Grade:29 | Tyler Guyton OT Oklahoma |
 30 | | Kool-Aid McKinstry CB Alabama | JC Latham OT Alabama | Jordan Morgan OT Arizona Grade:39 | Nate Wiggins CB Clemson |
 31 | | Roger Rosengarten OT Soph | Jackson Powers-Johnson IOL Oregon | Xavier Worthy WR Texas Grade:31 | Ricky Pearsall WR Florida |
 32 | | Xavier Legette WR South Carolina | Ladd McConkey WR Georgia | Adonai Mitchell WR Texas Grade:36 | Xavier Legette WR South CarolinaTrade |