Pick | Team | Mel Kiper 5.0 | Todd McShay 5.0 | Website Consensus |
 1 |  | Travon Walker DE Georgia | Travon Walker DE Georgia | Travon Walker DE Georgia Grade:91 |
 2 |  | Aidan Hutchinson DE Michigan | Aidan Hutchinson DE Michigan | Aidan Hutchinson DE Michigan Grade:94 |
 3 |  | Ikem Ekwonu OG NC State | Derek Stingley Jr. CB LSU | Ikem Ekwonu OG NC State Grade:90 |
 4 |  | Ahmad Gardner CB Cincinnati | Ikem Ekwonu OG NC State | Ahmad Gardner CB Cincinnati Grade:91 |
 5 |  | Charles Cross OT Mississippi State | Charles Cross OT Mississippi State | Evan Neal OT Alabama Grade:94 |
 6 |  | Evan Neal OT Alabama | Evan Neal OT Alabama | Charles Cross OT Mississippi State Grade:92 |
 7 |  | Jermaine Johnson II DE Florida State | Ahmad Gardner CB Cincinnati | Kayvon Thibodeaux DE Oregon Grade:94 |
 8 |  | Garrett Wilson WR Ohio State | Kayvon Thibodeaux DE Oregon | Garrett Wilson WR Ohio State Grade:92 |
 9 |  | Derek Stingley Jr. CB LSU | Jermaine Johnson II DE Florida State | Derek Stingley Jr. CB LSU Grade:94 |
 10 |  | Drake London WR USC | Garrett Wilson WR Ohio State | Drake London WR USC Grade:92 |
 11 |  | Chris Olave WR Ohio State | Drake London WR USC | Kyle Hamilton S Notre Dame Grade:94 |
 12 |  | Kayvon Thibodeaux DE Oregon | Kyle Hamilton S Notre Dame | Trent McDuffie CB Washington Grade:87 |
 13 |  | Kyle Hamilton S Notre Dame | Trevor Penning OT Northern IowaTrade | Jermaine Johnson II DE Florida State Grade:84 |
 14 |  | Jordan Davis DT Georgia | Jordan Davis DT Georgia | Jordan Davis DT Georgia Grade:90 |
 15 |  | Jameson Williams WR Alabama | Jameson Williams WR Alabama | Jameson Williams WR Alabama Grade:94 |
 16 |  | Trevor Penning OT Northern Iowa | Chris Olave WR Ohio State | Trevor Penning OT Northern Iowa Grade:89 |
 17 |  | Devin Lloyd ILB Utah | Kaiir Elam CB Florida | Zion Johnson OG Boston College Grade:86 |
 18 |  | Trent McDuffie CB Washington | Trent McDuffie CB Washington | Devin Lloyd ILB Utah Grade:90 |
 19 |  | Kenny Pickett QB Pittsburgh | Devonte Wyatt DT Georgia | Chris Olave WR Ohio State Grade:90 |
 20 |  | Malik Willis QB Liberty | Malik Willis QB Liberty | Malik Willis QB Liberty Grade:89 |
 21 |  | Daxton Hill S Michigan | Devin Lloyd ILB Utah | Nakobe Dean ILB Georgia Grade:93 |
 22 |  | Kenyon Green OG Texas A&M | Treylon Burks WR Arkansas | Treylon Burks WR Arkansas Grade:89 |
 23 |  | Zion Johnson OG Boston College | Jahan Dotson WR Penn State | George Karlaftis DE Purdue Grade:90 |
 24 |  | Tyler Smith OT Tulsa | Tyler Smith OT Tulsa | Kenyon Green OG Texas A&M Grade:87 |
 25 |  | Kaiir Elam CB Florida | Breece Hall RB Iowa State | Breece Hall RB Iowa State Grade:81 |
 26 |  | Jahan Dotson WR Penn State | Zion Johnson OG Boston College | Tyler Smith OT Tulsa Grade:83 |
 27 |  | Devonte Wyatt DT Georgia | Kenyon Green OG Texas A&M | Devonte Wyatt DT Georgia Grade:80 |
 28 |  | Christian Watson WR North Dakota State | Lewis Cine S Georgia | David Ojabo OLB Michigan Grade:92 |
 29 |  | Skyy Moore WR Michigan | Daxton Hill S Michigan | Jahan Dotson WR Penn State Grade:90 |
 30 |  | Arnold Ebiketie DE Penn State | George Pickens WR Georgia | George Pickens WR Georgia Grade:78 |
 31 |  | George Karlaftis DE Purdue | Quay Walker ILB Georgia | Tyler Linderbaum C Iowa Grade:91 |
 32 |  | Lewis Cine S Georgia | Kenny Pickett QB Pittsburgh | Matt Corral QB Ole Miss Grade:90 |